Published by Knopf

Calculate your own radiation dose

Take this questionnaire, Relative Danger of Energy Sources, and see how you score.

Home arrow Nuclear Energy FAQ arrow What about nuclear power plant safety and security?
What about nuclear power plant safety and security? PDF Print E-mail

— OR —
WHY A CHERNOBYL CAN NEVER HAPPEN IN THE U.S.

  • The Chernobyl reactor accident occurred under worst-case circumstances that involved the worst design, management by political hacks, and lack of a containment building. If the reactor had been contained there wouldn’t have been a dispersal of radioactive material.
  • All reactors in the United States, Europe, and Japan are enclosed within multiple barriers of containment. Reactor buildings are made of walls of dense concrete and steel that are 3 to 5 feet thick. The reactor fuel is enclosed in a thick steel pressure vessel.  The buildings are negatively pressurized to prevent outflow of any emissions.  In 1979 at Three Mile Island, a partial reactor meltdown occurred.  Thanks to the reactor vessel and containment building, there was no large-scale release of radioactive material to the environment.  Containment buildings are the most robust structures on earth.  A plane flying into one would be crushed, although hitting a target that small is virtually impossible.
  • In 1988 Sandia National Laboratories in USA performed a test to find out what happens when an aircraft impacts a massive, hardened target. A rocket-propelled F4 Phantom jet (about 27 metric tons, with heavy engines, both close together in the fuselage) rammed into a  12-foot thick slab of concrete at 500 miles per hour. This was part of a study to determine whether a proposed Japanese nuclear power plant could withstand the impact of a heavy aircraft. Most of the collision energy went into the destruction of the aircraft itself - about 96% of the aircraft's kinetic energy went into the its destruction and some penetration of the concrete, while the remaining 4% was dissipated in accelerating the 700-tonne slab. The maximum penetration of the concrete in this experiment was 2 inches.
    http://www.break.com/index/concreteplane.html
  • American nuclear plants are designed to operate as safely as possible and contain multiple backup systems to make sure the reactor is kept properly cooled.
  • Every American nuclear plant is required to have inspectors from the Nuclear Regulatory Commission on site and ready to shut down the reactor at the slightest suggestion of a serious problem.
  • Reactor operators must undergo stringent psychological and performance tests and must spend many years in training before being permitted in the control room.
  • Just as pilots train on aircraft simulators, reactor operators train for many years on nuclear plant simulators so that they will respond quickly and appropriately to a wide variety of accident scenarios.
  • The nuclear power industry is motivated to police plants carefully because the whole industry can be damaged by problems at a single plant.
  • American nuclear plants have multiple security barriers.  These have been enhanced since 9/11.  Access to a nuclear plant is extremely difficult. Heavily-armed guards, jersey barriers, checkpoints, turnstiles, and other security measures are in place. Very few people are permitted near the reactor building or the control room.
  • Polls indicate that the majority of people who live around nuclear plants are satisfied that they are safe and do not object to additional nuclear plants being built.
  • In 2006, a poll conducted by the Los Angeles Times and Bloomberg about energy and global warming found that most respondents think we must take prompt action. When asked about nuclear power, 61% favored it as a way to reduce greenhouse gases. Among those in the under-thirty age group, support was 71%. Trends in other polls also indicate a growing consensus about the necessity of increased nuclear power.
  • Take this questionnaire, Relative Danger of Energy Sources, and see how you score.  http://www.quaker.org/fep/reldangersquestions.html